Method
This page says what is in the collection, how an account is read, what counts as an outcome, and what the collection cannot support.
What is in the collection
| Count | What it is | |
|---|---|---|
| People registered | 59 | Anyone whose account the project set out to find |
| People with a source on file | 42 | At least one memoir, interview, talk or post has been saved |
| People with no source yet | 17 | Listed, nothing read |
| Older structured readings | 33 | An earlier pass that filled in a fixed form for each person |
| Compared episodes | 12 | One stretch of one person's practice, from 11 people |
| Course records | 4 | Published studies of a course, each kept as its own unit |
| Practice logs listed | 928 | Public forum diaries, not yet read |
Being registered is not a claim that someone awakened. The 42 sourced people have 57 source entries between them, drawn from 44 saved source files.
| Kind of source | Entries |
|---|---|
| Memoir or own writing | 33 |
| Interview | 15 |
| Biography | 3 |
| Other public writing | 3 |
| Forum or blog post | 2 |
| Talk | 1 |
People were chosen to spread across traditions, so this table shows what the project went looking for.
| Chosen to represent | People | With a source |
|---|---|---|
| Contemporary lay | 12 | 11 |
| Advaita | 8 | 7 |
| Kashmir Shaivism | 8 | 6 |
| Theravāda | 7 | 5 |
| Western esoteric | 7 | 1 |
| Christian contemplative | 3 | 2 |
| Secular | 3 | 3 |
| Vajrayāna | 3 | 3 |
| Zen | 3 | 3 |
| Christian background | 1 | 0 |
| Dzogchen | 1 | 0 |
| No tradition | 1 | 0 |
| Not assigned | 1 | 1 |
| Sufi | 1 | 0 |
Everything is public writing. Nobody has been contacted, interviewed or enrolled.
How an account is read
The unit of comparison is an episode: one stretch of one person's practice. Each episode records what the person did, what they report, what came before, what else was going on at the time, what follow-up exists, where in the source it is found, and which teachers or sources it shares with other episodes. Stretches that went nowhere are kept.
8 of the 12 episodes share a teacher or a source with another episode, so they are not independent of each other.
The 33 older readings have not been checked again against their sources as a whole. In 11 of them, fields known to be in dispute are set aside until re-read. The field most often set aside is years of practice before the change, in 8 readings. A field set aside is treated as unknown, never as a no.
What counts as an outcome
Four things are kept apart, because accounts use the word awakening for all of them:
- a first recognition
- a lasting change in how self and world are perceived
- practical development: conduct, steadiness, ease
- an attainment named by the person's own tradition
What the 12 compared episodes report:
| The episode ends with | Episodes |
|---|---|
| Reports the change | 3 |
| Partial benefit first, then reports the change | 1 |
| Reports the change, with difficulties later | 1 |
| Reports the change, and a separate emotional change | 1 |
| A change that closed up again within hours | 1 |
| Benefits; says the change did not happen | 1 |
| Benefits and some difficulty; says the change did not happen | 1 |
| A change of method; no awakening reported in this source | 1 |
| Some benefit; no awakening reported | 1 |
| Compares concentration states; no new awakening reported | 1 |
Four rules go with every reading. An account that is silent about something has not shown it was absent. A stretch of practice without result is not a permanent failure. People in courses are never added to the people in the stories. And a training that fits a learner has not thereby been shown to work.
What to look for in an account
One list holds every factor the project thinks may matter: 39 of them in 7 groups. Each is a candidate. For each one an account either shows it, shows it absent, or does not say. Not saying is the usual answer and is never read as absent.
| Group | Factors | Already a field | Shown in skimmed logs, of 48 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Where the person startsYears of practice before the change, Tradition or traditions trained in, Suffering and others | 6 | 4 | 46 |
| Qualities of mind: the seven factors of awakeningMindfulness, Investigation, Energy and others | 7 | 0 | 44 |
| What the person actually doesStructured investigation or noting of experience, Direct inquiry, or allowing without control, Loving-kindness or caring attention and others | 8 | 3 | 45 |
| Concentration statesJhāna reached, How jhāna was entered, kept apart from the state reached, Investigation done in or straight after absorption and others | 5 | 0 | 38 |
| Dose and settingDaily practice time, Retreat, Teacher contact and others | 5 | 5 | 46 |
| What sets it offA teacher's intervention or pointing, Pressure, then a release of habitual control, Sudden or gradual | 3 | 2 | 30 |
| After the changeSupport and interpretation after an opening, A testing period, Integration into conduct and daily functioning and others | 5 | 3 | 34 |
17 of the 39 are already a field in the registers, 12 are discussed only in case write-ups, and 10 are new. The seven factors of awakening have not yet been recorded on any account.
The full list
Where the person starts
- Years of practice before the change
- Tradition or traditions trained in
- Suffering: present, how severe, how long, how close to the event
- Self-aversion or distress that blocks practice
- A specific neglected capacity or inner conflict
- Life conditions at the time: work, family, health, loss
Qualities of mind: the seven factors of awakening
- Mindfulness: steady remembering of what is happening now
- Investigation: looking closely at how experience is put together
- Energy: sustained, willing effort
- Joy: rapture or gladness arising in practice
- Tranquillity: calm of body and mind
- Concentration: collected, undistracted attention
- Equanimity: evenness toward pleasant and unpleasant
What the person actually does
- Structured investigation or noting of experience
- Direct inquiry, or allowing without control
- Loving-kindness or caring attention
- Devotional or heart-centred practice
- Embodied or energy practice
- Imaginal practice
- A change of practice after a plateau
- Effort against force: steady effort, or straining
Concentration states
- Jhāna reached: which, and by whose definition
- How jhāna was entered, kept apart from the state reached
- Investigation done in or straight after absorption
- Stable attention short of jhāna
- Cessation events
Dose and setting
- Daily practice time
- Retreat: how many, how long, how recent
- Teacher contact: how often, and whether present at the event
- Peers or community
- A structured program or course
What sets it off
- A teacher's intervention or pointing
- Pressure, then a release of habitual control
- Sudden or gradual
After the change
- Support and interpretation after an opening
- A testing period: destabilisation, old material surfacing
- Integration into conduct and daily functioning
- Further shifts later
- Durability: does it last, and who says so
Practice logs
The stories are thin on ordinary students, on people for whom nothing happened, and on people who stopped. Public practice logs cover that ground: dated diaries written before the writer knew how things would turn out. A directory lists 928 of them by 613 authors, 648 from Dharma Overground and 280 from the Kenneth Folk Dharma archive. Being listed is not being read. No text from any log is held, and no author is named on these pages.
| Step | Logs |
|---|---|
| Logs listed | 928 |
| Withheld because the author asked not to be shared with AI | 2 |
| Skimmed | 48 |
| Worth a careful read | 21 |
| Possibly worth it | 13 |
| Not worth it: too short, a question thread, or no record of practice | 9 |
| Held back: personal details the author later regretted sharing | 5 |
The 48 skimmed logs come from 29 authors. 42 state how long the author practised each day and 17 describe a retreat. 23 have a timeline a reader could lay out in order. 12 authors say they work with a teacher; 31 have only advice from other forum members. The 21 logs worth a careful read hold about 385,000 words.
The skim was one quick reading per log by a language model, to decide what to read carefully. It judged nobody's attainment. The sample was drawn evenly across what the directory says each author claims, so these shares are not the shares in the whole set.
Limits
- Most accounts are by teachers and by people for whom something happened.
- An account is the person's own telling, usually years later, and almost none is checked by anyone else.
- Compared episodes cover 11 of the 42 sourced people.
- The 33 older readings follow an earlier form and have not been re-read as a whole.
- 17 registered people have no source on file.
- No practice log has been read closely, and the readers so far are language models.
The data files are in the project repository: the people, the episodes, the course records and the factor list.